Have you ever wondered why the “perfect” candidate sometimes flops while an underdog rises to the top? The answer is potential. They had the ability to adapt, learn, and grow into complex roles and environments. When industries evolved at a predictable pace, hiring based on experience made sense. But since entering an era where industries and jobs shift so quickly that it’s impossible to predict what skills your employees will need even a year from now? Potential is far more important than experience.
Why Experience Isn’t As Important
For decades, companies used to rely on competencies: proven skills and experience. But that was during a time where industries, jobs, and technology grew at a predictable pace. Where companies could afford to hire someone new a few years later to make up for the shift. Now, the world is changing faster than ever.
- A software developer’s coding language can be obsolete in five years
- A marketing manager’s channel strategy may be irrelevant by next quarter
- A leader’s “tried-and-true” management style might fail in a hybrid work setup
So if you’re still hiring for what’s on paper, you’re setting yourself up for stagnation. And you will fall behind.
How Potential Is Replacing Experience
Put simply, potential is the raw capacity to grow, adapt, and manage ambiguous situations. It’s replacing experience because no amount of past success guarantees someone can succeed in a job that may look completely different a year later. Skills get outdated, but the ability to learn and willingness to evolve stay relevant. By hiring people for who they can become (not what they’ve done) you’re guaranteeing your future success as industries, jobs, and technology grow and change. It’s a competitive advantage that no amount of experience can buy.
Real World Examples of When Potential Beats Experience
1. A mid-sized SaaS company hired a VP of sales with decades of industry experience. He knew all the big players, but when the market shifted to a subscription model, he struggled to adapt. His experience became a weight because he couldn’t unlearn new habits.
2. A retail chain took a chance on a store manager with no big-brand experience but a proven record of building engaged teams at a local co-op. Within a year, she’d turned a struggling branch into a region’s top performer because she was driven to learn, experiment, and rally her people.
3. A startup hired a junior marketer fresh out of college. He didn’t know their CRM but asked the right questions, watched online courses, and proposed digital campaigns that boosted leads by 30%. His potential outpaced the seasoned marketer who was adamant on sending newsletters in the mail vs creating a new email campaign.
How to Measure for Potential
So how do you actually measure something that doesn’t show on a resume? The solution is simple: talent assessments. Talent assessments are tools designed to identify a candidate’s competencies, behaviors, and drivers. All of which help you see how someone naturally thinks, adapts, and approaches challenges they’ve never faced before. For example, you might discover that a candidate works well under pressure and stays motivated even when things get messy. This information signals to you that they’ll keep up when the role evolves.
Final Thoughts
Experience might get someone in the door, but potential will keep your company moving forward. So, before you hire the candidate who looks perfect on paper, ask yourself: “do they have what it takes to tackle the challenges ahead?” It’s your insurance policy in a world where change is the only constant. Hire for potential, invest in growth, and watch your people (and business) succeed.
About Hiring by Design
For over 27 years, Tricia Neves—founder of Hiring By Design—has helped more than 100 organizations build people-first teams. Her approach goes beyond resumes and interviews by revealing a candidate’s behaviors, drivers, competencies, and potential risks. The result is a detailed, data-driven roadmap that gives employers the confidence to make smarter, more strategic hiring decisions.

