TL/DR: Talent assessments can improve employee retention, but they can’t guarantee it. Assessments provide insights that can help organizations align, engage, and develop employees. Whether they stay depends on whether the company acts on it.
A question I often get from new prospects experiencing turnover is some version of “what retention increase can you guarantee?” My answer is always, “I can’t.” Not because I lack confidence in my work. I’ve been assessing candidates for nearly 30 years. But guaranteeing retention would mean promising something I can’t control: what happens after someone is hired.
Can talent assessments improve employee retention and, if so, how? Let’s walk through it together.
Important Statistics to Consider
You can hire a candidate who has all the credentials you asked for, the experience you wanted, and the assessment results to back it up. But if the culture is toxic, they may leave. If they report to a manager with a track record of burning through people, they’ll leave. If they don’t get the support and resources they need, they’ll leave.
In iHire’s 2025 Talent Retention Report, workers who had left a job most often pointed to:
- A toxic or negative work environment: 26.8%
- Poor company leadership: 24.2%
- Being unhappy with their manager or supervisor: 22.8%
Meanwhile, only 13.4% of employers blamed a toxic environment, and just 9.1% blamed poor leadership. That disconnect matters. If employers don’t recognize the issues driving turnover, how can they address them? And many of those issues have little to do with the person they hired.
What Retention Depends On
Alignment
Alignment is the match between a person’s natural talent traits and what the role requires to be successful. Someone can have the right experience and still be misaligned, requiring them to rely heavily on traits that don’t come naturally while their strengths go underutilized. That builds stress and frustration over time. Clearly defining what success requires in the role, then comparing those requirements to a person’s natural talent traits, can help identify potential friction before it becomes a problem.
Engagement
Engagement is the quality of someone’s connection to their work for as long as they’re with you, not how many years they stay. It includes whether they’re engaged in the job they were hired for, or interested in another role at the company. Understanding how someone communicates and what motivates them gives managers valuable insight into how to engage that individual, along with a starting point for ongoing conversations.
Development
Good employee development starts with a long-term development plan that’s part of onboarding and tied to what the person wants from their career. It includes ongoing training and career paths that don’t trap someone in a single silo. Assessments can help identify strengths to build on, competencies to develop, and areas where additional support may be beneficial. That makes development more relevant to the individual rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach.
What Talent Assessments Can Tell You
Depending on the assessment, these tools can provide insight into:
- Behavioral tendencies
- Core motivations
- Decision-making and judgment
- Professional competencies
Together, these insights can help organizations make better-informed decisions, understand what motivates employees, and identify opportunities for development. But the real value comes from applying that information, not simply collecting it.
Understand Why Someone Left
Every company has its own definition of successful retention, often measured by how long someone stays. But being attached to that number can make you miss the quality of someone’s work while they’re with you. If someone gives you three exceptional years and makes changes that improve the whole company, was that hire a failure because they left?
People leave for reasons that have nothing to do with engagement: a spouse gets transferred, a parent needs care, or someone goes back to school for a master’s degree. Counting those departures as hiring failures misses the point, especially when some roles are designed to be short. So check why someone left. Maybe it had nothing to do with alignment, engagement, or development, and was simply circumstantial.
Do Assessments Improve Retention?
Anyone who guarantees you a retention rate is promising something they can’t control. Retention depends on the environment, engagement, and development of an employee. While talent assessments won’t keep someone in their seat, they can provide valuable insight into what may help keep that person engaged. It’s up to the organization to act on that information.
If you’re struggling with turnover and aren’t sure what’s driving it, let’s talk. Through Talent Lifecycle By Design™, I help organizations examine their hiring, onboarding, development, and other talent practices to identify gaps that may be contributing to the problem. Send me a message to set up a time.
Want the Full Playbook?
At Hiring By Design, we equip leaders with the tools and frameworks to take the guesswork out of hiring so you can start hiring by design. Grab the full hiring playbook: Identifying and Engaging the Best Talent for Your Business

