3 Changes to Help Avoid Underperforming Employees

Mar 6, 2025

Employee performance isn’t just about their skills or experience. It’s about aligning an employee’s natural talent traits with a role to maximize their potential. What many managers don’t realize is this needs to start before the first interview. If you’re experiencing turnover, disengagement, or underperformance, the cause might be how you’re approaching hiring.

In this blog, we’ll look at the most common causes of workplace underperformance and introduce three key changes to help you build a high-performing team.

 

Why Do Employees Underperform?

There are several reasons why employees may underperform. The most common are related to the working environment rather than the individual. Here are some common reasons to be aware of:

  • Lack of Clear Expectations: Employees perform best when they know what success looks like. Avoid shifting responsibilities, writing vague job descriptions, or providing unclear performance metrics, as these can lead to confusion and underperformance. Clear expectations help employees stay focused and aligned with company goals.
  • Limited Growth Opportunities: When employees don’t see a future at a company, they will slowly disengage. Unclear advancement paths and lack of skill development opportunities can lead to frustration and demotivation. Providing a clear career path and opportunities for growth keeps employees invested in their work.
  • Low Support: Employees need more than a paycheck to feel valued. Leaders must provide feedback, recognize achievements and create a sense of purpose. A supportive environment helps boost engagement, motivation, and performance.

 

3 Changes to Help Avoid Underperforming Employees

1) Understand Who You’re Hiring

Managers often look at hiring as ‘filling a role,’ often prioritizing candidates with the most experience or highest skill set. But this mindset completely misses things like what engages someone to perform at peak levels or whether they’ll thrive in a role. The key to a high performing team is to look past a resume and understand an employee’s natural talent traits. This allows you to align their natural strengths with the demands of the role.

A talent assessment is the fastest way to evaluate an individual’s drivers, behavior traits , and strengths. We use these assessments to predict if a candidate is likely to perform well and stay engaged in a specific role.

Example: If you’re hiring a commission based sales position, a candidate who is driven by financial incentives and rewards is likely to excel in that role. These individuals enjoy competition, do well under performance-based compensation, and are motivated by return on investment. 

2) Understand The Role You’re Hiring For

Many hiring managers focus on filling a vacancy rather than defining what success in the role actually looks like. This leads to misalignment between the new hire and the demands of the job. To avoid this, it’s important to establish job benchmarks. A job benchmark is a data-driven framework used to assess what is needed in a role. It creates a performance blueprint, eliminating confusion about  the role and what outcomes it is expected to achieve.

Example: You’re hiring a Sales Manager and creating a a job benchmark. You determine that one success factor is increasing revenue by 20% within the first year. Knowing this, you’ll need to look for someone who is  highly persuasive, is goal oriented, and is driven by ROI in every action they take. When you assess candidates, you can match their talent traits to the job requirements to find if they’re a match or not.

3) Understand How To Engage Employees

Hiring doesn’t end at an accepted offer. If you’re not actively nurturing and developing your employees, disengagement can occur—leading to underperformance and low morale. To build a high-performing, engaged workforce you need to create an environment where employees feel valued, supported, and driven. This requires structured approaches to onboarding, development, and engagement strategies.

Example: You create a job benchmark for a Marketing Specialist and use a talent assessment to find a great fit. Instead of assigning them repetitive tasks, you choose to invest in learning and career development to create a sense of purpose and progress by: enrolling them in a digital marketing certification course, allowing them to lead smaller campaigns to build confidence, and scheduling a quarterly career check-in to discuss future growth opportunities.

 

The Hiring By Design Approach

Most hiring mistakes happen before the first interview. If you’re only focused on filling roles instead of building careers, you’re setting yourself up for constant turnover and disengagement. By understanding who you’re hiring, what the role truly requires, and how to engage employees, you’ll create a workforce that’s productive, loyal, and aligned with your company’s goals.

Here at Hiring By Design, we specialize in aligning employees with roles to maximize potential and performance. We achieve this through our talent assessments and job benchmark strategies. If you’re struggling with underperforming employees, send us a message. We can quickly help you identify gaps and match the right people in the right roles.

Download our guide to Identifying and Engaging the Best Talent for Your Business to easily incorporate these changes and streamline your hiring process.